People safety

The hierarchy of controls, in plain English

A small factory floor with a guarded machine, a waist-height conveyor and a marked walkway.

Short answer: The hierarchy of controls is a way of choosing the best fix for a hazard. You start with the most effective options, getting rid of the hazard or swapping it for something safer, and only move down the list when those aren’t reasonably practicable. Engineering fixes come next, then rules and training, and personal protective equipment (PPE) comes last. Most good solutions combine several levels.

Watch: Missing Guard, about 90 seconds. See the episode →

Also: Label the Decant, Dust You Cannot See, Seal and Check →

Two answers to the same problem

Two packing businesses in Adelaide have the same problem: workers lifting 20 kg cartons off the floor all day, and sore backs to show for it.

The first business runs a manual handling course every year and buys everyone a back belt.

The second business moves the cartons onto a pallet stand at waist height, and splits the order so cartons are 12 kg instead of 20. Then it trains people in the new setup.

Both businesses “did something”. Only one of them changed the work. That’s the idea behind the hierarchy of controls.

The levels, from most to least effective

LevelWhat it meansExample
1. EliminateGet rid of the hazard altogetherBuy pre-mixed product so nobody decants chemicals
2. SubstituteSwap it for something less hazardousUse a milder cleaning product that does the same job
2. IsolateSeparate people from the hazardFence off the forklift area with barriers and gates
2. EngineeringChange the plant, equipment or setupFit a guard to a machine; use a pallet stand or lifter
3. AdministrativeRules, procedures, signs, trainingA lockout procedure; a toolbox talk; warning signs
3. PPEGear people wearGloves, safety glasses, hearing protection

In the model WHS Regulations, substitution, isolation and engineering sit together as the second level. Administrative controls and PPE are the last resort, used for whatever risk is left.

Why training and PPE come last

Training and PPE only work if a person remembers, is able to, and chooses to, every single time. On a busy shift, tired or rushed, that’s a lot to ask. A guard on a machine protects the worker on their worst day. A sign beside an unguarded machine doesn’t.

That’s not to say training doesn’t matter. It does: people need to know why the controls are there and how to use them. But training works best on top of a well-designed job, not instead of one.

How to use it

  1. Pick one hazard, such as lifting cartons from the floor.
  2. Start at the top. Can we remove it? Can we swap it for something safer? Write down why not, if not.
  3. Work down the list, adding controls until the risk is as low as you can reasonably get it.
  4. Combine levels. A pallet stand (engineering), a two-person rule for heavy items (administrative) and gloves (PPE) together beat any one alone.
  5. Ask the people doing the job. They’ll know what works and what will be ignored.
  6. Check it’s working. Watch the task a week later. Are people using the new setup?

Examples from SafeLee episodes

  • Missing Guard: the guard is the engineering control; the “don’t run it unguarded, report it” rule is the administrative backup.
  • Label the Decant: a pre-printed label for every product is an administrative control. It makes the right thing easy, but it still relies on people reading and following it.
  • Bottom of the Pallet: lifting the load to a better height changes the task itself.

What the law says, in plain English

A business has to eliminate risks as far as it reasonably can. If it can’t, it has to reduce them, starting with substitution, isolation or engineering controls, then administrative controls, and finally PPE. It also has to keep the controls working and check them. Victoria has its own law with a similar approach.

Toolbox talk: three questions for your crew

  1. What’s one hazard on our site that we’re only managing with a sign or a rule?
  2. Could we remove it, or change the equipment instead?
  3. Which control here do people work around, and why?

Common questions

Is the hierarchy of controls a legal requirement?

In the jurisdictions that use the model WHS laws, the order of controls is set out in the WHS Regulations. In Victoria, the approach is similar under its own regulations.

Is PPE ever enough on its own?

Sometimes, for low risks where nothing higher up is reasonably practicable. But it should be a deliberate choice, not the first idea.

Who decides what’s “reasonably practicable”?

The business, weighing up the risk and what can be done about it. Cost only counts if it’s grossly out of proportion to the risk.

Sources

© SafeLee. Share or quote with a link back to this page.

Check the rules where you work

Safety laws are similar across Australia, but each state and territory has its own regulator, and Victoria has its own Act. Choose where you work for your regulator’s guidance.

  • WorkSafe Queensland Queensland

    Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld)

  • SafeWork NSW New South Wales

    Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (NSW)

  • WorkSafe Victoria Victoria

    Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Vic): a different law with similar duties. Victoria uses compliance codes rather than the model codes of practice.

  • SafeWork SA South Australia

    Work Health and Safety Act 2012 (SA)

  • WorkSafe WA Western Australia

    Work Health and Safety Act 2020 (WA)

  • WorkSafe Tasmania Tasmania

    Work Health and Safety Act 2012 (Tas)

  • WorkSafe ACT Australian Capital Territory

    Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (ACT)

  • NT WorkSafe Northern Territory

    Work Health and Safety (National Uniform Legislation) Act 2011 (NT)

  • Comcare Commonwealth

    Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Cth)

  • Safe Work Australia

    Model WHS laws and model codes of practice. A national policy body, not a regulator.

General information only, not legal advice. Safety laws differ between states and territories and change over time. Check the law that applies where you work, follow your site procedures, and talk to your regulator or a WHS professional about your workplace. SafeLee episodes and guides support, and don’t replace, workplace-specific training, supervision and risk assessment.

Lea and Lee, the SafeLee safety characters, in orange hi-vis and hard hats.

Training that sits on top of good controls.

SafeLee episodes show the mistake, stop and ask, then show the safer setup, in about a minute and a half, with quick questions and a record of who completed it.